Handcrafted · Custom · Made to order

A cheesecake as special as the moment.

Sweet Lilly’s creates rich, handcrafted cheesecakes personalized with the flavors, toppings and finishing touches you love — made fresh in Fishers, Indiana.

Request your cheesecake Explore flavor ideas →

Please allow at least 48 hours’ notice whenever possible.

Chocolate s'mores cheesecake topped with toasted marshmallows, graham crackers and chocolate drizzle

MadeFreshfor you

Made freshfor every order

Custom creationsbuilt around your idea

Local pickupdetails confirmed personally

No online paymentrequest now, confirm later

Made with care

Custom cheesecakes without the complicated ordering process.

Choose a size, share the flavor or style you have in mind, and tell us about any toppings, crust preferences, colors or special details. Sweet Lilly’s will follow up to confirm availability, final pricing and pickup information.

Not sure what you want yet? Browse the popular flavor ideas below and use them as a starting point.

Simple starting prices

Choose your cheesecake size

Final pricing may vary depending on specialty ingredients, decorations and custom requests.

4”

Personal cheesecake

$35

Most popular6”

Small celebration

Starting at $55

8”

Classic gathering size

Starting at $70

10”

Large celebration

Starting at $85

A little something extra

Cheesecake bites

$3 each or 1 dozen for $30.

For businesses & events

Wholesale options available

Please contact Melissa directly at melissa@mysweetlillys.com for wholesale inquiries.

Need inspiration?

Popular cheesecake ideas

These are examples of flavors Sweet Lilly’s has created before—not a fixed menu. Use one as inspiration or request something completely custom.

Bright & fruity

LemonKey LimeCherryStrawberryPiña ColadaOrange DreamsicleWhite Chocolate RaspberryChocolate Covered Strawberry

Chocolate lovers

PB Reese CupOreoDeath by ChocolateChocolate ChipS’mores

Rich & specialty

TurtleToffee CrunchSalted CaramelWhite Chocolate Grand MarnierNew York (Plain)

Previous creations

Made by Sweet Lilly’s

S'mores-inspired chocolate cheesecake — **S’mores inspiration**Chocolate, toasted marshmallow and graham cracker

Reese's peanut butter cup cheesecake with chocolate drizzle — **PB Reese Cup**Peanut butter cups and chocolate drizzle

Pecan-topped cheesecake with whipped cream — **Pecan creation**Whipped topping and pecan garnish

How it works

From idea to pickup

Choose a size

Select a 4”, 6”, 8” or 10” cheesecake.

Share your idea

Describe flavors, toppings, crust, occasion or design details.

Confirm the details

Sweet Lilly’s will contact you about pricing, availability and pickup.

Enjoy

Pick up a freshly made cheesecake created especially for you.

Fresh from Sweet Lilly’s

More Sweet Lilly’s Creations

A few more recent favorites and ideas to inspire your custom order.

Cheesecake Bites

Perfect for parties, sharing, or a little something sweet.

Request Cheesecake Bites

Classic Inspiration

A clean, elegant cheesecake style for celebrations or simple cravings.

Request Something Similar

Chocolate Specialty

A richer, chocolate-forward option for custom orders and special occasions.

Request Something Similar

Start your order

Tell us what you have in mind.

This is an order request, not a final purchase. Sweet Lilly’s will contact you to confirm the details, price and pickup arrangements.

48-hour notice requestedMore elaborate designs may require additional time.